Community Developments Investments (Fall 2013)
Using the Public Welfare Investment Authority to Make Wind Energy Investments
Courtesy of David SchwartzThe Goodnoe Hills Wind Project, in Klickitat County, Wash., uses wind turbines manufactured by REpower, which makes both onshore and offshore wind equipment.
National banks and federal savings associations (FSA) have broad authority to make loans and extend credit.1 The public welfare investment (PWI) authority permits national bank and FSA investments in wind energy facilities if the investment is "designed primarily to promote the public welfare, including the welfare of low- and moderate-income (LMI) communities or families (such as by providing housing, services, or jobs).2 FSAs may make investments in wind energy facilities under PWI authorities similar to those of banks."3
Wind energy projects do not automatically qualify as PWIs. Federal regulations permit national banks and FSAs to make a PWI if the investment primarily benefits LMI individuals, LMI areas, or other areas targeted by a governmental entity for redevelopment, or the investment would receive consideration as a “qualified investment” under 12 CFR 25.23 of the Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) regulations.4
Using the PWI authority, national banks and FSAs may invest in wind energy-producing facilities, directly or indirectly (i.e., by taking interests in the entities themselves, or in funds that hold wind energy facilities), if the beneficiaries or the location of the facilities are consistent with the requirements of the PWI authority.5
One way to demonstrate benefit to LMI individuals under the PWI authority, for example, is to show a reduction in energy costs in an affordable housing development. Alternatively, a wind energy-producing facility’s location might provide a basis for permitting an investment in such a facility to qualify as a PWI, because that authority allows national banks and FSAs to invest in projects that primarily benefit LMI areas.
Also, the facility could be located in an area targeted by a governmental entity for redevelopment.6 Most often, the designation will cover a neighborhood, district, or other geographic area under a formally adopted redevelopment plan that includes special activities and benefits or funding from public and private resources. A governmental entity may include any legally incorporated town, city, county, tribal, or federal governmental agency or entity. Examples of formally designated redevelopment areas include federal empowerment zones, brownfield sites, rural communities, state enterprise zones, or city tax incremental financing (TIF) districts.
The final category involves a “qualified investment” under the CRA regulations.7 Some investments in wind energy-producing facilities may be considered qualified investments if the facilities revitalize or stabilize low- or moderate-income areas or rural, middle-income, underserved, or distressed communities.8 Also, an investment that promotes economic development by financing small businesses may be considered a qualified investment.9 This could include, for example, an investment that finances a small business, where the small business either installs wind turbines or manufactures the turbine’s components.
When the location of the wind energy-producing facility forms the basis for qualifying under the public welfare authority, a national bank or FSA must also demonstrate that there is job creation in order to meet the public welfare standard.10 For example, if a project is located in an LMI area and creates permanent jobs, the institution typically would be able to provide a sufficient basis for establishing the public welfare benefit. For wind energy-producing facilities, permanent jobs primarily involve maintenance and servicing.
The Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council’s Web site, www.ffiec.gov, can be used to find a list of distressed or underserved census tracts. Median family income statistics and a geocoding system to map census tract level information on area median income can also be found on that Web site, although a specific address is necessary to use the geocoding system. For large wind energy arrays located in rural areas, where an address may be unavailable, other data sources may help pinpoint family or area income by county or census tract. Policymap.org is another data source for evaluating area income and includes mapping tools. The U.S. Census Bureau also provides census tract maps by county at www.census.gov.
Certain safety and soundness considerations and limitations apply to all PWIs. A national bank’s aggregate investments under the PWI authority cannot exceed 5 percent of the bank’s capital and surplus, although this limit may be increased up to 15 percent if the OCC approves a national bank’s proposal requesting regulatory permission to exceed the 5 percent limit for its aggregate PWIs.11 Investment limits governing these activities for FSAs differ from those for national banks and vary depending on which legal authority is being used to make the investment.12 Finally, a PWI may never expose a national bank or FSA to unlimited liability.
The OCC has approved investments in wind energy installations under the PWI authority:
National banks seeking to invest in wind energy generation facilities under the PWI authority must either submit a prior approval notice to the OCC before making an investment or, if the national bank meets the eligibility standards, submit an after-the-fact notice to the OCC. Even if an eligible national bank meets the after-the-fact notification requirements, the national bank should consult with the OCC Community Affairs Department to discuss whether its proposed investment will qualify as a PWI. The OCC currently is in the process of integrating the PWI requirements for FSAs into the agency’s regulations. In the meantime, FSAs seeking to make PWIs should comply with the former Office of Thrift Supervision’s PWI requirements. FSAs should also consult with the OCC before they make an investment in a wind energy transaction in order to seek assurances from the OCC regarding this determination. The OCC has developed a "Public Welfare Investments" Fact Sheet that provides information about the requirements for PWIs and the procedures for filing notices and securing approval from the OCC for an investment.
For questions about whether specific investments may qualify as PWIs, or for information on the OCC’s approval process for PWIs, contact Karen Bellesi at (202) 649-6420. More information is also available at the OCC’s PWI Web Resource Directory.
112 USC 24 (Seventh) for national banks and 12 USC 1464(c) for FSAs.
412 CFR 24.3.
6A national bank or FSA making an investment that relies on these criteria should maintain information documenting that the governmental entity or agency has designated the area; the redevelopment criteria for the area; how the PWI is consistent with the governmental entity’s or agency’s plans; and the type of financing and other support that the governmental entity or agency provides to the area or project in which the investment is made.
712 CFR 25.12(t).
8See “Interagency Questions and Answers Regarding Community Reinvestment,” __.12(g)(4)(iii) – 3 and – 4, for more guidance on what is considered to revitalize or stabilize a non-metropolitan, middle-income, distressed, or underserved area.
912 CFR 25.12(g)(3). The definition of community development includes activities that promote economic development by financing businesses or farms that meet the size eligibility standards of the Small Business Administration's Development Company or Small Business Investment Company programs (13 CFR 121.301) or have gross annual revenues of $1 million or less. See “Interagency Questions and Answers Regarding Community Reinvestment,” __.12(g)(3) – 1, for guidance on promoting economic development by financing small businesses and farms.
1012 CFR 24.6(b)(3) and (4).
1112 CFR 24.4.
1212 CFR 160.36 and 12 CFR 559.